top of page

On Conversation

The Elephant in the Room

Why conversation asks more of us than acknowledging that other perspectives exist.


The Bhagavata explains how spirituality can transcend sectarian religion and how it is, in fact, the essence of religion. Take, for example, the statements of Queen Kunti, who, nearing the end of her life, prayed to be done with everything, including religiosity. This was also expressed by Krishna in the Bhagavad-gita when he advised Arjuna to abandon all varieties of religion and simply surrender to him. In these contexts, religion refers to the perfunctory aspects of religion—not to its spiritual essence.


This idea of spiritual essence being beyond religion means that no specific religion—or institution—has a monopoly on spirituality. This may seem obvious, but there are many religious groups that claim a monopoly over spirituality. Why in today’s age is it such a challenge for people of one faith to recognise saintliness outside of their own tradition?


Religious texts from many traditions acknowledge that there is one divine reality, though called by different names. One 19th-century follower of the Bhagavata, Bhaktivinoda Thakura, spoke of how when he visited churches and mosques, he thought, ‘Here is my own Lord, being worshipped in a different way.’ The Bhagavata explains that the names, forms, qualities, and activities of the divine are interpreted differently by different teachers according to their respective scriptures and that divinity accepts the devotion of everyone.


An ancient Indian tale speaks of a group of blind men who came across an elephant. Each man touched a different part of the elephant and came up with their truth of what an elephant was. One felt the trunk and described it as a snake. Another touched the tusk and described it like a spear. Another the leg and thought it was a tree. And so on. We each experience different parts of the same truth. People all over the world experience ‘spirituality’ but in different ways:


• We see different aspects of the same reality, so we might disagree. One might see a trunk, and another an ear.


• We speak different languages, and have different worldviews and cultures, so much is often ‘lost in translation’.


• We see different aspects of the same reality and, through dialogue, might illuminate each other.


Now, let’s take it one step further. What if the blind men are asked to not only understand but also accept the truth of each other’s experience? This scenario more accurately reflects the true extent of some of our biggest challenges in real life. Is it surprising, then, that universal spirituality is not more common? But if we have information about the concept of an elephant, even if our limited experience doesn’t entirely match the whole description, we can at least theoretically comprehend the bigger picture. This will help us make sense of our own experiences and the perspectives of ‘differing’ others. And through dialogue, and our own evolving spiritual journey, the elephant emerges in all its fullness.


Source: Before Religion, Chapter 1, “Spiritual but Not Religious”, from “The Elephant in the Room”, printed pages 8–11.

Other pieces in this line

Cultural Bias

→

Beyond Clearing the Mind

→

When Enthusiasm Becomes Steadiness

→

Reading Beyond the Words

→

Our Nature Is Not Fixed

→

A Teacher Helps Us See

→

The Love Within the Offering

→

Fire as a Teacher

→

Living in the World Without Being Absorbed by It

→

A Little Bit More

→

To Love and Be Loved

→

The Elephant in the Room

→

Love That Responds

→

Hands, Heads and Hearts

→

The Constant Chase

→

From Resolution to Habit

→

Goodness Is in the Details

→

The Need to Be Special

→

Watering the Seed

→

What Emerges Between Us

→

The Patience Payoff

→

Obstacles on the Path

→

Bringing the Mind Back

→

bottom of page