On Conversation
Cultural Bias
Understanding the assumptions behind another person’s argument before dismissing their conclusions.
Everyone thinks of others according to their own perspective. It is how we, with our inbuilt biases, see the world—as an extension of our own selves.
While logic and reason help us overcome bias, logic is only as good as the premises on which it is built. For example, the argument that ‘if everything must have a creator, who made God?’ poses a premise that spiritual nature must have the same requirement of causation as material nature. This ignores the possibility of an entirely different set of parameters. While physical objects must have a cause, spiritual objects do not have the same requirement. We may agree or disagree with the premises—it is a matter of belief—but for something to be considered logical, it must be internally consistent. Something can’t be labelled illogical just because the premise doesn’t fit with our worldview.
Many scriptural texts have been composed for a particular time, place, and circumstance, sometimes to deliver a message to a specific audience. This may mean certain aspects of the message are being highlighted while other non-essential messages are being set aside. With this understanding, we can see how a seeker from one cultural context may learn a principle, such as compassion, from someone from a different tradition—perhaps even better than they might from their own.
When considering different cultures, we should be wary of assuming superiority simply because we can’t identify with them. Since Western civilisation has roots in ancient Greece and Rome, there is natural acceptance of those philosophies and philosophers. We may struggle with the idea that other world civilisations may have been even more developed or that ancient Western civilisations borrowed much from them. This was exemplified by colonisers for centuries, who viewed cultures they didn’t understand with contempt, labelling them primitive. It was then only a short step to justify their exploitation, enslavement, conversion, and even genocide. Not recognising the spirituality and philosophies that characterised many ancient civilisations, they tried to wipe them out or forcefully convert them to their own brand of monotheism, tainting the term ‘monotheism’ and showing the danger of interpreting cultures and philosophies according to one’s own cultural assumptions.
Source: Before Religion, Chapter 2, “On Religion”, complete section “Cultural Bias”, printed pages 27–28.