top of page

On Human Nature

Our Nature Is Not Fixed

The difference between repressing our impulses and gradually changing the conditioning behind them.


The Bhagavata speaks of our worst instincts as something to be acknowledged and tamed, focusing not on our tendency to do bad but on our struggle to be good. Socrates said, ‘The secret of change is to focus all of your energy not on fighting the old, but on building the new.’ But, of course, there are challenges even in building the new. In the Bhagavad-gita, Arjuna asks, ‘By what is one impelled to sinful acts, even unwillingly, as if engaged by force?’ Added to this internal pressure, is our instinctive need to conform even when it goes against what we know to be right (the Lucifer Effect). We experience these pressures daily and in every aspect of our lives.


The modes can flag our susceptibilities and help us avoid just taking the path of least resistance whenever we are tempted. But it is not simply about repressing ‘lower’ urges; Krishna warns of the dangers of repression: ‘Even a man of knowledge acts according to his own nature, for everyone follows his nature. What can repression accomplish?’


The difference between repression and self-control is that there is no transformation with repression—it is a forced imposition, with desires bubbling away just beneath the surface, waiting for an opportunity to burst forth. We must change our nature (here, I don’t mean our essential spiritual nature) gradually through the modes by replacing lower tastes with higher ones. Since our nature in this regard is only conditioning built up over time, it is transitory and can be changed to reveal our underlying and non-transitory spiritual nature. If this were not the case and our characters were not at least somewhat malleable, there would be little meaning to education or training.


Ignorance and Passion are the more troublesome modes, but the terms are not meant to suggest value judgments. Nor are they evil forces; they are natural aspects of the human condition, and by monitoring their role in our motivations, we can become more thoughtful and purposeful in our decision-making.


Passion has a place, but in our ever-evolving lexicon, it has been elevated to a desired value. We are encouraged to ‘feel passionate’ about our work and lives and forget that passion has a dark side: ‘a barely controllable emotion’. But boom can turn to bust, winning can lose its thrill, tastes can change, relationships can grow stale, and the satisfaction from status can fade. Passion, it turns out, can be a kind of drug, lifting us up and then letting us down. We crave more. Like an addiction, it requires ever-increasing levels of stimulus to yield feelings of equal excitement. And when we don’t get that excitement, we retreat into Ignorance.


Krishna’s words in the Bhagavad-gita, that ‘the person who is not disturbed by happiness and distress and is steady in both is certainly eligible for liberation’, can help us get started. ‘Not being disturbed’ by happiness may seem counterintuitive: why would we be disturbed by happiness? An addiction to dopamine spikes—to material happiness—causes diminishing returns and suffering. We can now also see that dopamine cycle effects correlate exactly with what the modes framework predicts. But we may still ask why we should start with tolerating happiness: because happy feelings have a weaker hold on the mind than negative ones. The easiest way to train ourselves is to begin by trying to stop identifying so strongly with the highs. When we get used to tolerating the highs, tolerating the lows becomes easier. The stoicism of Goodness aims at a deep and lasting contentment rather than the addiction to peak moments.


Those immersed in Passion and Ignorance believe gratifying the senses is the prime necessity of human life. They are thus implicated in a network of unlimited desires and resultant anxiety. The ancients understood this concept: the Latin root, passio, means suffering or enduring. Christ’s Passion is the story of Jesus’ persecution, not his miracles. Although the popular interpretation has changed over time, the basic nature of passion has not: it is transitory and unsustainable. The cycle of creation (Passion), preservation (Goodness), and destruction (Ignorance), therefore, is no longer a surprise.


To shift out of Ignorance, through the excitement and activity of Passion, and on to Goodness takes practice and hard work until it becomes second nature. Goodness requires an intentional thought process, and that can start out feeling austere. There are some who might argue that if it’s hard work, then it can’t be natural, and if it can’t be natural, then it can’t be spiritual. That is a very weak argument: a young child finds learning to walk hard work; it doesn’t mean it’s not natural. One challenge of Goodness is to accept that the benefits, especially at first, may be unseen or difficult to identify. They cannot be measured in the same way in which we calculate success or failure.


Before Religion Chapter 9, “Human Behaviour”, consecutive sections “Making Choices” and “Negative Behaviours”, printed pages 127–130.

Other pieces in this line

Cultural Bias

→

Beyond Clearing the Mind

→

When Enthusiasm Becomes Steadiness

→

Reading Beyond the Words

→

Our Nature Is Not Fixed

→

A Teacher Helps Us See

→

The Love Within the Offering

→

Fire as a Teacher

→

Living in the World Without Being Absorbed by It

→

A Little Bit More

→

To Love and Be Loved

→

The Elephant in the Room

→

Love That Responds

→

Hands, Heads and Hearts

→

The Constant Chase

→

From Resolution to Habit

→

Goodness Is in the Details

→

The Need to Be Special

→

Watering the Seed

→

What Emerges Between Us

→

The Patience Payoff

→

Obstacles on the Path

→

Bringing the Mind Back

→

bottom of page