On Modern Life
A Little Bit More
Why getting what we want so often leads to wanting something else—and how we confuse relief, pleasure and lasting happiness.
Ironically, we can really be happy only once we stop endeavouring so hard for happiness! Like an itch screaming to be scratched, our desires don’t usually abate when we try to fulfil them: they worsen. The best way to deal with an itch is to tolerate it. This ability grows with Goodness. Obviously, there are some ‘itches’, like hunger and thirst, that can and should be satisfied in a balanced way.
There is never a time when we feel we have enough pleasure, enough wealth, enough power; we always want more. As the business magnate John D. Rockefeller replied when asked how much money was enough, ‘A little bit more.’ So, we might pursue our pleasures to some degree, but in Goodness, we do so knowing that:
A) sometimes, destiny will simply not allow it;
B) what pleasure we do manage to derive will be temporary; and,
C) we won’t be fully satisfied by it because our real need is spiritual.
While a person in Goodness will also try to fulfil desires, they do so in moderation, trying not to get sucked into the never-ending cycle of desire, temporary fulfilment, disappointment, and repeat. Desires are more manageable when kept in their place, but when they become the focus of our lives, they are insatiable.
Somehow, even in the most horrid conditions, we can convince ourselves that we are enjoying ourselves. This is not a sage’s equanimity and self-satisfaction, born of detachment and knowledge, but the delusion that we are ‘having a good time’, born of Ignorance. We confuse the alleviation of suffering with happiness. This is like the ‘happiness’ felt by a person being dunked underwater and allowed to come up briefly for a gasp of air.
The external energy casts two kinds of spells: diversion, which impels us to remain absorbed in sense gratification, and delusion, which makes us think we are enjoying ourselves even when rotting in the most miserable conditions. Put another way, the mistaken idea that there is any real pleasure outside of the Self is our ignorance feeding the diversion, and our acceptance of suffering as pleasure is the delusion.
We can even be deluded about our past experiences. Psychologists have seen that our recollection of experiences focuses on our peak and last emotions during those experiences. We tend to omit the in-between stuff, which constitutes the vast bulk of our actual experiences, and retain a skewed version of the past and how much we loved or hated it.
In each species of life, the Self finds a particular type of enjoyment and is illusioned not to question or be averse to that condition. Thus deluded, the Self feels little inclination to think beyond the material body. Each species of life is endowed with the ability and inclination to tolerate its respective tortures. The Bhagavata tells the story of a great denizen of heaven who was cursed to become a hog. When the time came for him to be relieved of this curse and take on a heavenly body, he refused, saying that he was quite content in his new hog life! We may not become hogs, but the same delusion affects even the best of us.
An ancient, somewhat cantankerous ascetic named Daksha argues that one cannot give up material ‘enjoyment’ unless one personally experiences how much suffering it entails. He recommends, therefore, that we cultivate material enjoyment and knowledge simultaneously. His theory is that simply through our experience and suffering, we will eventually find material enjoyment abhorrent. He reasons that those whose minds are changed by others do not become as detached as those whose minds are changed by personal experience. This has become a common line of reasoning. The Bhagavata cautions us against this risky strategy since our desires for material enjoyment are so powerful and unending that we almost never become disgusted enough to desist. And although we can indeed learn from our mistakes, we can also learn in other ways, including from good advice and from observing the mistakes of others.
Source: Before Religion, Chapter 10, “The Human Condition”, from “How to Be Happy?”, printed pages 141–144.