On Practice
Hands, Heads and Hearts
Why practice brings thought, action and intention together—and how discipline can increase our freedom.
Arjuna appears confused. Previously, Krishna conveyed some profound spiritual insights that would help Arjuna change his perspective and overcome his dilemma. Krishna recommended sankhya (analytical knowledge) to distinguish the Self from the body, and buddhi (intellect) as the type of yoga he recommends. These seem, on the surface, like purely intellectual endeavours. But Krishna also told Arjuna to act in the world, dedicating the results of his dutiful work to Krishna. This confuses Arjuna because these methods seem contradictory – one engaged in physical activity and the other two apparently not. Arjuna asks for clarification: does Krishna want him to intellectualise his way through life or does he want him to act in the world?
The question betrays a common but mistaken assumption that persists even today: that the yoga system is made up of discrete paths. Krishna clarifies that physical activity and intellectual pursuit are not opposed. We can integrate different aspects of yoga according to our individual choice, and factors such as our level of knowledge or detachment, all of which evolve over time as we advance.
We can now reconcile Krishna’s recommendations in Chapter 2 of the Gita as follows: buddhi-yoga (known also as bhakti-yoga) is the combination of intellectual analysis (sankhya-yoga, known also as jnana-yoga) plus dutiful action (karma-yoga), all lovingly dedicated to divinity. Buddhi/bhakti-yoga = hands + heads + hearts. It is a most natural path because it accommodates our tendency to act, and it is efficient because from the outset it explicitly cultivates the link between the Self and divinity.
Karma-yoga starts by regulating material desires, such as regulating wealth by avoiding unethical means to amass wealth or regulating sex by marriage. At first glance, such types of regulation appear to be restricting our freedom. However, like traffic restrictions lead to an overall increase in driver freedom, these restrictions aim at increasing our overall ability to exercise free choice in our lives. And contributing a portion of the fruits of our labours is part of karma-yoga to help us develop detachment. Through this combined process of regulation and contribution, we experience a newfound capacity for detachment and free choice. If we are too attached, too driven by habit or addiction, we cannot express free choice. Think of someone who makes a choice to start smoking – by the time they are on their thousandth cigarette, they are no longer expressing free choice. Whereas, if we are detached, not driven by the demands of our mind and senses, habit or addiction, we find ourselves able to express more free will.
The self-realised person, however, surpasses this stage of dutiful action because their every act is impelled by something greater...but Krishna leaves this matter there for now and will explain more in Chapter 5.
Many readers of the Bhagavad Gita are puzzled by why Krishna sometimes uses karma-yoga interchangeably with buddhi/bhakti-yoga. He does this because karma-yoga can be used as an umbrella term for the full spectrum of dutiful action, from dedicating a portion of our labours to some greater cause, all the way to acting out of love for the divine.
It is impossible to not do doing anything at all, even for a moment. Try it and see! Our minds will quickly get the better of us. We are pleasure-seeking beings, and we are constantly making ‘choices’ – sometimes good, sometime bad – to maximise pleasure. And until we reach enlightenment, we act almost helplessly according to our own psycho-physical nature, even if our intelligence prompts us to do something else. As we learned in the last chapter, repression will not work. Therefore, rather than risk being a pretender – by artificially stopping worldly activity to pursue spirituality – Krishna recommends that we simply regulate and dovetail our activity with a spiritual purpose.
The 5-minute Gita, Chapter 3, “The Art of Work”, PDF pages 15–17.