When Science Describes the World but Cannot Fully Explain Experience
Consciousness, meaning and the limits of reductionist thinking.
Field Of Enquiry
VI: Integration of Wisdom & Reality
PHILOSOPHICAL ENQUIRY
Yoga and meditation are widespread globally as methods for fitness, flexibility, and relaxation, but their original purpose was to help bring the mind under control and then help link us with the Ultimate Reality. The entire yoga system draws us from matter to consciousness. Yoga systems are best known for their focus on the breath or posture. I want to bring the reader’s attention to a lesser-known version of yoga (sankhya-yoga) that is based on the idea that through careful observation, reason, and contemplation, we can arrive at spiritual conclusions and realisations. The practitioner of sankhya comes to two main realisations: a) that the body is dependent upon something other than inert matter, and b) that there exists a conscious observer.
The first realisation, that there is something beyond (and ontologically prior to) matter, is a result of a process deduction. The seeker in sankhya-yoga first categorises the material elements as fundamental building blocks of existence. They then realise that having accounted for all the elements and their combinations, they still cannot account for consciousness. They arrive at this conclusion by deduction, or via negativa, which in Sanskrit is called neti-neti, ‘not this, not that’. What was identified through sankhya remains the ‘hard problem of consciousness’ even today: we still don’t understand how a physical stimulus in the brain translates into an experience, the precise transition from a living body to a dead one, or the ‘birth’ of consciousness. The process of sankhya concludes that this is because consciousness is primary and matter is epiphenomenal—not the reverse. This last point has been evidenced thoroughly by Iain McGilchrist in his book, The Matter With Things.
The second realisation, that there exists an observer, is sometimes dismissed prematurely by meditators who lean toward nihilism. The Bhagavata tells us that the presence of the Self can be detected by three states of consciousness: wakefulness, sleep, and deep sleep. In all three states, the spiritual Self is the observer. That there is an observer can also be inferred by the presence of such things as personality and thoughts, just as the presence of air can be understood by the aromas it carries. This observer is currently in something like a dream state, in which one enjoys and suffers falsely, based on a fundamental misidentification with the body as the Self. To bring us to the point of awakening, beginner meditators are often encouraged to reflect on their breath and body, gradually recognising that since they are observing these functions and bodily limbs, they must, in fact, be different from them, separate from the body. As one continues beyond these initial stages of meditation, a natural sense of spiritual oneness arises as our material concept of self begins to dissolve. At this early stage, people feel a sense of relief and peace, and sometimes even the loss of individual identity that comes from feeling part of a whole. For those who progress further in yoga meditation, there is then the emerging positive concept of the Self in relation to the Ultimate Reality.
Using solely our intelligence and analytical inclinations, sankhya brings us to the brink of spiritual awakening, from where we can glimpse an ultimate reality.
Before Religion - Chapter 3, “Spiritual Lessons from Everyday Life”, section “Philosophical Enquiry”, printed pages 38–39.