Why “Who Am I?” Is Still the Most Difficult Question
Notes after writing Before Religion.
Field Of Enquiry
III: Consciousness, Self & Meaning
The question ‘Who am I?’ is a good starting point for any spiritual enquiry. Imagine looking at your reflection in an agitated pond of water. You appear to quiver due to the nature of the water. We need to wait till the water is still before we can see ourselves as we truly are. And so it is with the Self—the still, spiritual nature of the Self is at odds with the rippling material nature in which it sees itself. We are duped if we think ourselves like the rippling reflection, just because that’s what we first see. We are similarly duped if we mistake our spiritual Self of limitless potential for our material body, with its very limiting constraints. Having attained a human form and the capacity for spiritual enquiry, it behoves us not to waste it but rather search for essential truths: a life less ordinary.
Sanatana Goswami (1488-1558) was the treasurer to the Mughal ruler of Bengal. He was highly educated and very accomplished, so much so that the Mughal ruler once remarked that he depended entirely on Sanatana’s advice. But Sanatana’s real interest lay elsewhere; he wanted to become a follower of Chaitanya Mahaprabhu. He was imprisoned for trying to resign from his position but eventually managed to escape. When he met Chaitanya, he expressed that while people considered him a great scholar, he did not even know what was truly beneficial for his own self-interest. He asked, ‘Who am I? Why am I suffering? Without knowing the answer to these questions, how can I be benefited?’ Such honesty, humility, and sincerity are hallmarks of an ideal spiritual seeker.
Every entity has its dharma, its essential nature—its qualities and functions. (There are other types of dharma—such as contextual, social, moral, and religious—but we will ignore those for now as we focus on our essential nature.) Let’s use the example of fire; the essential qualities of fire are heat and light. The heat and light of fire remain dormant until there is fuel, something on which fire can act and through which its dharma can manifest. The essential functions of fire are to burn and to illuminate. This essential dharma is incontrovertible; it cannot be changed. However, improper fuel can appear to temporarily distort it; for example, adding magnesium to a flame turns the flame white. Whatever we focus our consciousness on is the fuel through which our essential nature manifests.
The Vedanta-sutra summarises the essential nature of the spirit as anandamayo ’bhyasat, bliss-seeking. It is worth pointing out that using the word ‘bliss’ to translate ‘ananda’ indicates not just pleasure, happiness, or meaning alone, but a combination of all three, resulting in utter fulfilment. Wherever we think there is bliss, be it in money, power, relationships, and so on, there we deposit our faith and work to extract it.
The Bhagavata uses the terms sat, chit, and ananda to describe the essential spiritual nature. The Self, being of that same nature, is constitutionally these same three things: eternal and unchanging (sat), conscious and the knower (chit), and blissful (ananda). And this combination of eternity, cognisance, and bliss delineates the full scope of spiritual reality—not eternity alone, not even eternity with knowledge, but eternity, knowledge, and bliss. It is our inherent nature to want to be blissful—we are just looking in all the wrong places.
Our essential spiritual qualities of eternality, cognisance, and bliss relate to our ability to make choices, to understand, and to enjoy. These qualities and functions are what distinguishes consciousness from inert matter. This unchanging nature of the Self prompts us to think beyond our usual concepts of self. The Self is not born and does not grow, decline, or die. It is pure perception, an embodiment of pure consciousness, and at the same time possesses the quality of consciousness.
Our nature remains dormant until we choose a ‘fuel’ on which to focus our consciousness. And as with fire, if we choose unsuitable fuel, by focusing on the temporal, our essential nature—our spiritual qualities and functions—will appear distorted. Only when we choose a suitable fuel do we experience our dharma.
In other words, a suitable fuel is one that nourishes an entity’s inherent dharma. Through our own experience, we can see for ourselves what qualifies as suitable fuel towards which to direct our consciousness. Which practices, environments, or people raise my consciousness to experience eternality, cognisance, and bliss? Which help me exercise more free will, understand more fully, and find more lasting joy? Make them your fuel.
It’s worth noting the implications of an essential and incontrovertible dharma of the Self. They have a significant bearing on the Bhagavata’s vision of inclusivity. It means that beyond any ‘faith’ or ‘religion’, which clearly can change based on choice, we share a common essential nature that unites us all.
Before Religion Chapter 4, “Who Am I?”, printed pages 53–56